Charmed viewers floored over cast switch up in original pilot episode

Charmed fans were gobsmacked after stumbling upon snippets of the original pilot episode which features a different actress in the role of Phoebe. The hit supernatural drama series tells the tale of the Halliwell sisters - Prue, Piper and Phoebe - who unearth their destiny as the "Charmed Ones", learning they're extraordinarily gifted good witches destined to wield their new magical powers to protect innocents from evil.

In the first episode of the series, the three sisters reunite in their childhood home where they uncover the secrets of their ancestry; they're the latest in a long lineage of good , and each of them has distinctive supernatural abilities. aired for eight seasons, spanning from 1998 to 2006 and was a massive success, amassing a cult following that still persists today.

All prospective shows are pitched alongside a pilot episode, which aims to provide an accurate depiction of a show's premise and themes, while also showcasing the selected cast members in their respective roles.

READ MORE:

READ MORE:

Pilots are filmed and screened in an attempt to persuade producers and networks to give the green light to a show and commission a full first season.

Some pilot episodes end up serving as the official launch of a show, while others are re-filmed and, in certain instances, re-cast based on feedback from studio executives or other industry insiders.

In the unaired Charmed pilot, the character of Phoebe - portrayed by in the show's official run - was initially played by Lori Rom.

Phoebe, the youngest Halliwell sister - known for her power of premonition - starts off as a free-spirit but matures significantly through her trials as a Charmed One.

The eldest sister Prue was portrayed by , who sadly died in 2024 after a lengthy ordeal with . Prior to her death, Doherty had made waves with her podcast Let's Be Clear, inviting old co-stars and industry insiders to discuss their journey in showbiz.

In one episode, she and former co-star , who played Piper Halliwell in Charmed, chatted about the show's original pilot episode.

Doherty described initial Phoebe actor Lori Rom as "wonderful" and commended her seamless fit into the cast, and her "quirky" touch.

Both actors disclosed that Rom backed out of Charmed due to the clash between its supernatural themes and her religious beliefs. Shannen respected her choice, commenting: "[It's] not the decision I personally would have made, clearly, but I do respect her for putting her faith and her values first."

replaced Rom in the role and crafted an unforgettable Phoebe, winning over the hearts of the fans and establishing herself as a firm favourite.

In a recent post on , a fan shared a string of images from the unreleased Charmed pilot, which shows Doherty and Combs as Prue and Piper, with Rom instead playing Phoebe.

The fan, shocked by this discovery, captioned their post: "Just found out that they shot the pilot with another actress playing Phoebe!"

This revelation sparked a flurry of speculation from viewers about what might have been if Rom had stayed on for the eight season run, while some die-hard aficionados were quick to mention this revelation was old news within the community.

Tensions between Alyssa Milano and Shannen Doherty were no secret; their strained dynamics led to a notorious shake-up at the end of season three.

Doherty left the series with her character Prue coming to a dramatic demise, paving the way for Rose McGowan to step in as surprise half-sister Paige Matthews – a love child of the Halliwell's mother and Sam, her Whitelighter, which is essentially a guardian angel of witches in the of Charmed.